Hat Heel Socks Pattern Review

I don’t have too much to blog about this week because the majority of it was spent working on my Hat Heel socks (which, at the time of this, still have about an inch of ribbing left to go on the cuffs, but I’m calling that good enough).  I found out in October last year that my parents absolutely love hand knit socks and needed more after the ones my grandmother knit them years ago have finally started to wear down.  They told me this, after I had already finished most of my Christmas knitting for them, but I had enough time to squeeze in a pair of socks for each of them.  This year, I’m going in with the plan to knit as many pairs of socks as I can.  I also set the goal (mostly so I don’t go crazy) that I would use a new pattern each time and try to learn a new skill with each pair.   This pattern had a few new techniques that I learned, so it was a good start to this project.

The Hat Heel sock is a pattern I found on knitty.com and was written by Kathleen Sperling.   It is a free pattern and I found it very clearly written.   The pattern may seem a bit long (6 pages) for a sock pattern, but most of it is introduction and explaining the construction technique.  Since the pattern is free, I’m not giving anything away by just inserting the general construction illustrations included in the pattern:
It is a very interesting construction, and one that I wouldn’t have thought of, but makes sense when you think about it.  This pattern also helped me think about hats in a new way since it never really occurred to me that I could knit them from the top down.  

The pattern includes sizes baby, toddler, small child, older child, woman, man.  I knit the man size, since these are a Christmas present for my dad.  The pattern is written row by row, with only a few sections where it says “repeat the above 6 rows until 6 stitches remain”.  So, for most of it, I would just make a little check mark next to the row number when I had completed it.  Sperling also links to other sites for more detailed instructions for the techniques used in the socks such as the Figure Eight cast on and Kitchener stitch.  Speaking of the Figure Eight cast on, that was another new technique for me.  The instructions that Sperling gives are clear, but I wanted something with some pictures, so I found this tutorial, which walked you through step by step with pictures, which I found extremely useful. 



While the instructions were very clear, I did find the first time knitting the heel portion to be a bit frustrating.  I found the small number of stitches on my DPNs to be very difficult to work with, especially since you start increasing immediately and trying to see the stitches needed to work the M1 increase as described in the pattern was difficult.  I probably made this problem worse by using Lang Yarns Ja Woll, which comes with reinforcement thread that you knit with the sock yarn.  So instead of 1 strand of yarn, I technically had 2.  But more than anything else, I think it was just  like learning any new technique and knowing that the first time isn’t going to go perfectly.  When I knit the second heel, it went smoothly and didn’t feel fiddly at all.  So I’m chalking that experience up to the knitter’s errors and not the pattern’s. 

Another part of the pattern that I didn’t love was picking up all the stitches.  I knew that I would be picking up stitches going into this pattern, and I saw a few modifications on Ravelry where people figured out how to do short rows so you didn’t need to pick up stitches.  However, I wanted to follow the pattern, at least for the first pair.  I see picking up stitches as one of the necessary evils when it comes to knitting, I don’t find it particularly difficult, but I still don’t like doing it.  In fact, once I finished the feet, these sat off the needles for a few days while I talked myself into picking up all the stitches for the leg.  I also picked up more stitches than the pattern called for because I know with size 1.5 needles and with this yarn, I need 72 stitches for my dad’s socks.  So I picked up a few extra and when it came to the toe decreases, I just had a few extra stitches at the toes, but I don’t think that is really going to be noticeable. 

I’m also not a fan of the Kitchener stitch, so to avoid it, I turned the sock inside out and did a three needle bind off.  Yes, this did leave a bit of a ridge on the inside of the sock, but I don’t think it is that noticeable or bothersome.  I do wish I had known about the Russian grafting technique that Very Pink Knits did a video on after I had already done the three needle bind off on my first sock.  I think that one would have been cool to try. 

So, to sum up: this pattern was very interesting and had a few new techniques for me to try.  I think the socks turned out great and they feel very sturdy.  Since my dad won’t be trying these on until later in the year, I don’t have a report for how they fit compared with other hand knit socks, but they look like they’ll fit very nice.  The pattern was extremely well written and easy to follow.  I found it easy to modify to fit my own preferences.  I found this a fun knit, but I don’t think it will be my go-to sock pattern.  I just don’t have enough of a dislike for the fit of other sock heels to go through the extra steps for this pattern.  I would be interested in maybe trying out the modification for short rows if I can find it again. 

Comments